Wednesday, April 30, 2025
Español
Courtroom 43 - Honorable Judge Benjamin F. Coats

Courtroom 43 - Civil Trials, Law & Motion

Law & Motion Matters and Hearing Calendar for Law & Motion

Absent unusual circumstances, Judge Coats will begin the law and motion calendar in Courtroom 43 at 8:45 a.m. Please check in with the courtroom clerk when the doors open at that time. If appearing by Zoom or CourtCall please check in before 8:20 a.m. The Court often publishes tentative decisions on law and motion matters at the end of the day prior to the hearing date. Please check the "Courtroom 43 Tentative Rulings" section below to see if a tentative decision has been published on your matter.

If you would like to submit on a tentative decision, you must send an email notifying the court and opposing counsel of your decision to submit without making an appearance. Please note: if you submit on a tentative decision and another party appears, the hearing will proceed in your absence. If all parties advise the Court that they submit on the tentative ruling, the Court will adopt the tentative and no appearance is required. Email submissions should be sent to the Court at: Courtroom43@ventura.courts.ca.gov with all parties copied on the email. In the alternative, you may send a fax to Judge Coats's secretary, Hellmi McIntyre at 805-477-5894, with copies to all parties.

REMOTE APPEARANCES IN COURTROOM 43:

IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT - ZOOM WILL BE AVAILABLE BEGINNING JULY 1, 2024.
TO APPEAR REMOTELY BY ZOOM YOU MUST FOLLOW THESE INSTRUCTIONS.

Pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure sections 128 and 367.75, and in the interests of convenience and economy, Judge Coats allows all attorneys and parties who appear for most proceedings calendared in Courtroom 43 to do so remotely by Court Call or Zoom in lieu of appearing in person. The parties may appear remotely by Zoom or Court Call for Zoom appearances, all counsel appearing by Zoom must email the court at Courtroom43@ventura.courts.ca.gov with a simultaneous copy to all other counsel/self-represented parties no later than 3:00 p.m. the court day before the hearing. INCLUDE THE PHRASE "ZOOM APPEARANCE ON (DATE OF HEARING)" IN THE SUBJECT LINE OF YOUR EMAIL. The email must identify the person who will make the appearance. You will receive the login information for your appearance in reply to your email. If appearing by Zoom, log into the hearing no later than 8:30 a.m. The Court will transfer you to the hearing room when your matter is called. Please make sure that the name that is seen on Zoom is the name (first and last) of the attorney making the appearance, along with the abbreviated case name (i.e., "Jones v Smith"). IF YOU DO NOT FOLLOW THESE INSTRUCTIONS, YOU WILL NOT BE PERMITTED TO APPEAR BY ZOOM AT THE HEARING.

REMOTE APPEARANCE BY ZOOM IS FORBIDDEN UNLESS THE ABOVE PROCEDURE IS FOLLOWED.
VIOLATIONS OF THIS ORDER MAY RESULT IN MONETARY SANCTIONS.

To appear by Court Call, visit www.courtcall.com or call 888-882-6878. Court Call registrations close by 4:00 p.m. the court day before the hearing (excluding weekends and court holidays).

Parties may appear by Zoom or Court Call for all calendar matters, including law and motion, minor's compromise, ex parte, Status Conference, Case Management Conference, and Trial Setting Conference hearings, unless a personal appearance is ordered by the Court. Judge Coats permits default prove-up hearings, some court trials (attorneys must appear in person) and other evidentiary hearings to be conducted by Zoom with leave of the Court by noticed motion or stipulation of the parties upon a request made by email to Courtroom43@ventura.courts.ca.gov not later than 30 days before the hearing or otherwise by order of Judge Coats.

Any request for a witness to testify by Zoom in a jury trial must be by stipulation of the parties, or by order of the Court, not later than 30 days before the trial or otherwise with leave of the Court.

All those appearing by Zoom shall comply with the following orders: (1) participants shall be dressed in business attire appropriate to the formality of the courtroom; (2) participants may not use virtual backgrounds; (3) participants shall be in a private, quiet location devoid of distractions, including loud noises; (4) participants shall not be driving an automobile or otherwise engaged in any activity which distracts from the ability of participants to focus on the court proceeding; (5) participants shall not use any filters or graphics which modify or alter the video image or voices of the participants; (6), participants shall behave in a manner consistent with proper courtroom decorum at all times; (7) if a participant is observing only and not permitted to speak during the hearing, then the participant shall mute their audio and turn off their video during the hearing unless otherwise directed by the Court; and (8) participants must ensure they have reliable internet access which provides uninterrupted audio and video connection during the Zoom proceeding. PLEASE NOTE: A willful or intentional violation of any of these orders may be punished by a monetary sanction pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 177.5, or by contempt of court, which may result in a fine of $1,000 or confinement in jail for up to five days for each violation.

All emails to the Courtroom 43 address must be simultaneously copied to all other attorneys or self-represented parties appearing in the action. Judge Coats will not respond to communications sent to the Courtroom 43 email address.

Courtroom Orders for Jury Trials in Courtroom 43 Download Courtroom Orders for Jury Trials in Courtroom 43 PDF Document

Courtroom 43 Tentative Rulings

Case Number Event Type Event Date/Time Department Document
202200569736CUMC Motion for Reconsideration 4/28/2025 8:20 AM 43 Tentative
2023CUPP014526 Motion to Vacate Default and Default Judgment 4/30/2025 8:20 AM 43 Tentative
202200573390CUOE Hearing on Motion for order approving PAGA claims 4/25/2025 8:20 AM 43 Tentative
2024CUCO020636 Motion to Strike Portions of the First Amended Cross-Complaint of Denise Watkins, successor trustree of the Roberta A. Swank and Charlotte L. Swank Family Trust 4/29/2025 8:20 AM 43 Tentative
2025CUOR038108 Motion to Consolidate Cases 4/29/2025 8:20 AM 43 Tentative
2024CUBT020141 Motion to Compel Production of Documents from Defendant 4/25/2025 8:20 AM 43 Tentative

Courtroom 43 Calendar

Event Date/Time Event Type Event Status Case Number Case Title Case Type Dept.
4/30/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Vacate Default and Default Judgment Scheduled 2023CUPP014526 BRICE vs PRANCERS PUMPKIN VILLAGE, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:30 AM Order to Show Cause re: RE: Entry of Default Scheduled 2024CUPP026314 MADRIGAL vs TARGET CORPORATION, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:30 AM CMC: Complex Track Scheduled 2024CUOE035021 NURER BILASH vs SIMI CDJR Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:30 AM Court's Further Status Conference Scheduled 201500474606CUMC The People of the State vs Voight Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:30 AM Case Management Conference Scheduled 2024CUPP026314 MADRIGAL vs TARGET CORPORATION, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:30 AM Case Management Conference Vacated 2024CUPP026314 MADRIGAL vs TARGET CORPORATION, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:30 AM Order to Show Cause re: Entry of Default Vacated 2024CUPP026314 MADRIGAL vs TARGET CORPORATION, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:35 AM Court's Order to Show Cause re: Dismissal Pursuant to Representation of Settlement Vacated 2024CUPP019157 RAMIREZ vs STERLING VENUE VENTURES, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:35 AM Case Management Conference (complex case) Rescheduled 2024CUOE020097 RODRIGUEZ vs CLINICAS DEL CAMINO REAL INC Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:35 AM Order to Show Cause re: Why monetary sanctions should not be imposed against Plaintiff's counsel and/or dismissal of the case pursuant to Local Rule 3.17 for failure to appear on 12/02/2024, 1/29/2025, 3/19/2025 and for failure to serve the complaint Vacated 2024CUPP025586 GREENBERG vs MURPHY Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUMM033105 LEYVA vs MOVAHHEDI DDS Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:35 AM Order to Show Cause re: why monetary sanctions should not be imposed against defense counsel, Gary Steven Spitzer, for failing to appear on 4/15/25, and sending an attorney who is unfamiliar with the case Scheduled 2024CUOE035021 NURER BILASH vs SIMI CDJR Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CLBC033125 ASPHALT PROFESSIONALS, INC. vs JAJOU, et al. Civil Limited 43
4/30/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Vacated 2024CUBC033133 DOMINGO MARTINEZ, et al. vs VOLKSWAGEN GROUP OF AMERICA, INC. Civil Unlimited 43
4/30/2025 8:30 PM Order to Show Cause re: RE: Entry of Default Rescheduled 2024CUPP026314 MADRIGAL vs TARGET CORPORATION, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:20 AM Motion for Order TO DEEM EACH REQUEST FOR ADMISSION, SET ONE, ADMITTED, OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, TO COMPEL RESPONSES Scheduled 2024CUPP026314 MADRIGAL vs TARGET CORPORATION, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel PLAINTIFF RITA GARAY MADRIGAL'S RESPONSES TO REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, SET ONE, PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS Scheduled 2024CUPP026314 MADRIGAL vs TARGET CORPORATION, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel PLAINTIFF RITA GARAY MADRIGAL'S RESPONSES TO SPECIAL INTERROGATORIES, SET ONE Scheduled 2024CUPP026314 MADRIGAL vs TARGET CORPORATION, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel Plaintiff Rita Garay Madrigal's Responses to Form Interrogatories, Set One Scheduled 2024CUPP026314 MADRIGAL vs TARGET CORPORATION, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:20 AM OSC - Name Change Scheduled 2025CUPT040958 IN THE MATTER OF: OLIVIA GRACE JUDGE Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUPP029111 GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA vs FREEDOM FOREVER LLC Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:35 AM Case Management Conference Scheduled 2024CUPP028039 WILLIAMS vs KELLER, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:35 AM Order to Show Cause re: Entry of default Scheduled 2024CUPP028039 WILLIAMS vs KELLER, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Vacated 2024CUCR033173 BOUYER vs DELANO GARDENS Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUPA033183 SIGUA, et al. vs EKSTEIN, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUPP033163 AGUILERA vs ALBERTSONS COMPANIES, INC., et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/1/2025 10:00 AM Status Conference Re: Status of closing briefs Scheduled 201900531293CUPO Ramos vs. Offshore Crane Civil Unlimited 43
5/2/2025 8:20 AM Motion For Order to Substitute Trustees of Two Trusts in Place for Deceased Defendant Phillip Shiver Scheduled 2024CUBC020879 GROOVER vs SHIVER, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/2/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS PURSUANT TO SUBPOENA BY BREMER, WHYTE, BROWN & O'MEARA LLP Scheduled 202300574303CUBC Hernandez vs. TV Oxnard Bliss LLC Civil Unlimited 43
5/2/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel Responses to Request for Production of Documents, Set Two and Order to Produce Documents Scheduled 202300574303CUBC Hernandez vs. TV Oxnard Bliss LLC Civil Unlimited 43
5/2/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUBC033272 SCHEIN vs M & M IRONWORKS, INC., et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/2/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUBC033330 YOKOYAMA vs AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/2/2025 8:35 AM CMC: Complex Track Scheduled 2024CUBT024729 SEMAIN vs PATAGONIA, INC. Civil Unlimited 43
5/2/2025 8:35 AM Case Management Conference /Status regarding transfer-in from Los Angeles Vacated 2023CUOR012253 KESHAP vs DEEPIKA WALI, AN INDIVIDUAL AND ALL PERSONS UNKNOWN, CLAIMING ANY LEGAL OR EQUITABLE RIGHT, TITLE, ESTATE, LIEN, O... Civil Unlimited 43
5/2/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUPP033311 HYNES & HALE, INC. vs TODD Civil Unlimited 43
5/2/2025 8:35 AM Case Management Conference Scheduled 2023CUOE013516 LOPEZ vs ADRIANA'S INSURANCE SERVICES INC. Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel RESERVED on behalf of plaintiff Reserved 2023CUPA011231 GUTIERREZ vs JACKSON, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel RESERVED on behalf of plaintiff Reserved 2023CUPA011231 GUTIERREZ vs JACKSON, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel RESERVED on behalf of plaintiff Reserved 2023CUPA011231 GUTIERREZ vs JACKSON, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel RESERVED on behalf of plaintiff Reserved 2023CUPA011231 GUTIERREZ vs JACKSON, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:20 AM Petition to Determine Identity Scheduled 2025CUPT040513 In the Matter of Monk T Failaugua Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel Complainance With Deposition Subpoena of Non-party, Andrew Thierry, M.d., and Request for Sanctions Vacated 2024CUPA024323 ZAMORA vs INGRUM Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:30 AM Default Prove Up Hearing Scheduled 202000544741CUCL Rojas vs. Ranieri Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:30 AM CMC: Complex Track Scheduled 2024CUOE028660 HERNANDEZ vs TOPSTAR FLORAL INC Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:35 AM Case Management Conference Scheduled 2024CUPP029475 NANEZ vs MV TRANSPORTATION, INC., et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:35 AM Order to Show Cause re: Entry of default as to Doe Defendant Kayshon Lee Scheduled 2024CUPP029475 NANEZ vs MV TRANSPORTATION, INC., et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CLNP033340 WILLIAMS vs TRUEACCORD CORP Civil Limited 43
5/5/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUBC033341 SCIFRES vs FCA US, LLC, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUCL033361 HENRY KURTZ vs RENETZKY Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 1:30 PM Jury Trial Vacated 2023CUPA007425 RAMOS vs GARCIA ROJAS Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 1:30 PM Jury Trial (7 days) Rescheduled 2023CUPP011445 VELAZQUEZ vs RALPHS GROCERY COMPANY Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 1:30 PM Jury Trial (10-days) Vacated 2023CUPP008433 DIAZ vs CHEDRAUI USA INC, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 1:30 PM Jury Trial (10-days) Vacated 202300575454CUPA Gandham vs. Priskin Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 1:30 PM Court Trial (5-Days) Scheduled 202000546911CUOR Fung vs. Soda Thousand Oaks LLC Civil Unlimited 43
5/5/2025 1:30 PM Court Trial (2-Days) Scheduled 202100561483CUPO Frost Baratta vs. Tipton Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel RESERVED on behalf of plaintiff Reserved 2023CUPA011231 GUTIERREZ vs JACKSON, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel RESERVED on behalf of plaintiff Reserved 2023CUPA011231 GUTIERREZ vs JACKSON, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel RESERVED on behalf of plaintiff Reserved 2023CUPA011231 GUTIERREZ vs JACKSON, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:20 AM Motion to Compel RESERVED on behalf of plaintiff Reserved 2023CUPA011231 GUTIERREZ vs JACKSON, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:20 AM Demurrer to Defendant's Answer Scheduled 2024CUBC032652 AHL vs CROWN DODGE Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:30 AM Case Management Conference Scheduled 2024CUPP026035 CHAVEZ vs SCHIMMEL, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:30 AM Case Management Conference Scheduled 2024CUPP027915 COUNTY OF VENTURA vs SCHIMMEL, et al. Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Vacated 2024CUCR033450 MARTIN vs DREAM HOUSE INTERIORS, INC. Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUBC033519 CLAVERIA vs VINFAST AUTO LLC Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:35 AM Trial Setting Conference Scheduled 2023CUBC016884 KIM, et al. vs STATE FARM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:35 AM Order to Show Cause re: Why Counsel Robert Kent should not be the lead attorney in this matter Scheduled 2023CUBC016884 KIM, et al. vs STATE FARM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:35 AM Case Management Conference Scheduled 2024CLBC030220 JPMORGAN CHASE BANK N A vs APODACA Civil Limited 43
5/6/2025 8:35 AM Order to Show Cause re: Imposition of monetary sanctions for failure to enter default pursuant to CRC Section 3.110(i) Scheduled 2024CLBC030220 JPMORGAN CHASE BANK N A vs APODACA Civil Limited 43
5/6/2025 8:35 AM Case Management Conference Rescheduled 2023CUOE007584 AARSVOLD vs LLC Civil Unlimited 43
5/6/2025 8:35 AM MANDATORY APPEARANCE CMC/Order to Show Cause Re Sanctions/Dismissal for Failure to File Proof of Service/Default Scheduled 2024CUPA033389 CANDELARIO LUJANO, et al. vs COOPER Civil Unlimited 43
© 2025 Superior Court of California, Ventura County